New York Bans Smart Glasses From Courts as Celebrity Backlash Grows
SMART GLASSES

New York Bans Smart Glasses From Courts as Celebrity Backlash Grows

The Short Version

New York will ban smart glasses from all 1,240 state courts starting July 20, arriving alongside a growing patchwork of gym and cruise bans and celebrity backlash.

Starting July 20, New York will ban Meta Ray-Bans and other smart glasses from all 1,240 state courts, even though the state already bans recording of any kind inside courthouses and doesn't extend that ban to phones, arguing the recording light on smart glasses is too easy to miss despite Meta already disabling the camera if that light gets covered or tampered with. Ironically,  Mark Zuckerberg's own security team wore smart glasses into a Los Angeles courtroom that already banned recording devices, and the judge threatened contempt.

Anyone can slide a phone into a pocket with the camera running, and phones aren't banned. Smart glasses get banned for being less obvious to spot, which makes how suspicious a device looks the standard instead of what it does. There's no single law behind any of it. No federal statute and almost no state statute addresses smart glasses directly, so courts, cruise lines, and gyms are each writing their own rules. Royal Caribbean bans them in casinos, spas, and medical areas across its ships. A UK gym chain banned them outright after member complaints.

That patchwork erases real accessibility use, live captioning and translation for non-native speakers and people with hearing loss, transcripts for witnesses giving technical or emotional testimony, to stop a threat that barely shows up in the record.

It's interesting to note that Live-streaming to Instagram and Facebook only ever worked on the original Ray-Ban Meta glasses, Meta's own support page confirms, and it never came to Gen 2 or the new Meta Glasses.

At a festival sponsored by Ray-Ban Meta, Lorde told the crowd she wants nothing to do with the glasses, and Tyler the Creator called anyone wearing them a "real weirdo" on Instagram. Both came right after Meta's biggest celebrity endorsement yet, a Kylie Jenner-designed pair called the Starfire.

Google Glass didn't die from a law. It died largely because nobody wanted to be seen wearing one, and to be fair the tech wasn't quite ready either, and the word people invented for that person stuck. A pop star on a stage can undo a year of ad spend in one sentence, and courts, cruise lines, and Lorde are all pulling in the same direction at once.