Compare Google Fitbit Air vs Garmin Cirqa
Battery
100% in 90 min 0–100% in about 90 minutes About one day of battery from 5 minutes Health
Yes Optical heart-rate sensor; 24/7 tracking Yes Wrist-based heart-rate monitoring Yes HRV status / overnight HRV Yes Red and infrared sensors; overnight SpO2 estimates Yes Device temperature sensor / skin-temperature variation Yes Irregular Rhythm Notifications supported Not confirmed
Irregular rhythm alerts limits
Uses optical pulse data, not ECG Not confirmed
Fit and build
5 ATM (50 m) · IPX8 APAC manual also states IPX8 None Screenless; status LED only Connected GPS via phone; no on-device GPS listed Connected GPS using a compatible smartphone Textile/Performance Loop 130–210 mm; silicone Small 130–175 mm, Large 165–210 mm Wrist S/M 24.5 × 2.4 × 0.2 cm; Wrist L/XL 28.5 × 2.4 × 0.2 cm; Arm S/M 36.0 × 2.4 × 0.2 cm; Arm L/XL 50.0 × 2.4 × 0.2 cm; Wrist band and arm band; fabric bands 5.2 g 12 g with standard band 14.8 g Module; 20.7 g with S-M band, 21.2 g with L-XL band Top of wrist, behind wrist bone Works with
iPhone and Android iOS 16.4 or later; Android 11 or later iPhone and Android Compatible iPhone supported; Compatible Android smartphone supported Options and ownership
Berry, Fog, Lavender, Obsidian
Black, Citron Gray, Mauve, French Gray, Dark Olive, Captain Blue, French Blue 15 days Starts the day it arrives Price
No for core tracking Google Health Premium is optional; $9.99/month after the trial No; $69.99/year for Garmin Connect+
From $99.99 (lowest of these two) Same on both
1 year Starts the day you buy it
Fitbit Air
Garmin Cirqa VSIs now a good time to buy?