Compare Garmin Instinct 3 vs Garmin vivoactive 5

Garmin Instinct 3

Garmin vivoactive 5

Battery

Battery
18 days Smartwatch mode: up to 18 days (45 mm) or 24 days (50 mm) 7 or 9 days with the display always on
Smartwatch mode up to 11 days (5 days with the display always on); battery saver up to 21 days; GPS up to 21 h
Charging
Garmin proprietary plug charger; solar charging on Solar models
Garmin proprietary plug charger

Health

Health sensors
Heart rate variability (HRV) status, Pulse Ox blood oxygen
Garmin Elevate wrist heart rate, Pulse Ox, accelerometer, compass, ambient light sensor, overnight heart rate variability (HRV) status

Fit and build

Display
AMOLED with an always-on option; 1.2 in (45 mm) or 1.3 in (50 mm)
1.2 in 30.4 mm AMOLED touchscreen, 390 × 390 pixels, optional always-on
Water resistance
10 ATM (100 m) Water-rated to 100 m; built to MIL-STD 810
5 ATM (50 m) Rated for swimming
Weight
53–59 g By size or material 53 g (45 mm) or 59 g (50 mm)
23 g 36 g with the included band
Design
45 × 45 × 14.9 mm or 50 × 50 × 14.4 mm; metal-reinforced bezel and fiber-reinforced polymer case
42.2 × 42.2 × 11.1 mm fiber-reinforced polymer case, anodized aluminum bezel, Gorilla Glass 3, 20 mm quick release bands

Works with

Works with
iPhone and Android, Garmin Connect app Quick text replies on Android only
iPhone and Android Garmin Connect; text replies and notification pictures on Android only
Connectivity
Multi-band GPS with SatIQ; Bluetooth and ANT+; LED flashlight
Bluetooth, ANT+, Wi-Fi

In the box

  • Garmin Instinct 3
  • Charging and data cable Garmin's own plug charger
  • Documentation
  • Garmin vivoactive 5
  • USB-C charging and data cable Garmin's own plug at the watch end
  • Documentation

Options and ownership

Colors
Black, Black/Charcoal, Neotropic, Neotropic/Twilight
Not confirmed
Case sizes
45 mm, 50 mm
Not confirmed
Warranty
1 year Starts the day you buy it
Not confirmed
Return window
30 days
Not confirmed

Price

List price
From $349.99
From $269.99 (lowest of these two)
Availability
Available now
Available now Previous generation

Same on both

Payments
Yes Garmin Pay contactless payments
Price checked Nov 22, 2026We may receive a commission

Which should you buy?

See our pick

How it compares

See all comparisons

Is now a good time to buy?