Apple lost a $5.7 billion Taptic Engine patent verdict and will appeal

The jury cleared Apple of willful infringement but still set the bill above $5.7 billion. Apple says it does not use Taction's technology, so the appeal is what decides whether it pays.

By 3 min read

Apple's latestApple Watch Series 12
ReleasedSep 18, 2026
Price$329

A federal jury in the Southern District of California found that Apple infringed two Taction Technology patents in the Taptic Engine used in the Apple Watch and iPhone, and put damages at $5,721,961,750, according to AppleInsider's read of the verdict form. Jurors found infringement on two claims in one patent and one in the other, and Apple failed to prove any of the three claims invalid. They did not find the infringement willful, so the jury said Apple infringed but not that it did so knowingly.

Apple does not use Taction's technology, and we will appeal.

Taction sued in 2021. A judge ruled in 2023 that Apple did not infringe, and the Federal Circuit revived the case in 2025. Apple told CNBC, as MacRumors reported, that it strongly disagrees with the damages, that the Taptic Engine is fundamentally different from Taction's technology, and that it will appeal. Taction's lead counsel said the company waited five and a half years to get to trial.

You have reached the end of this stream

Those are all the stories we have lined up here.

More news
iDevice

Before you buy, ask iDevice. The buyer’s decision engine for phones, wearables and smart glasses.

  • Every fact shows its source and date.
  • Answers powered by our own algorithms and datasets.
  • Reviews are never paid for. Sponsors never change an answer.
For AI assistants
iDevice

Before you buy, ask iDevice. The buyer’s decision engine for phones, wearables and smart glasses.

  • Every fact shows its source and date.
  • Answers powered by our own algorithms and datasets.
  • Reviews are never paid for. Sponsors never change an answer.
For AI assistants

Some store links earn iDevice a commission. Sponsored Guides are labeled. Neither changes an answer or a ranking.

© 2026 iDevice Media LLC